Connect with us

News

Supreme Court explains restoration of AmaewhSupremeule-led leadership of Rivers Assembly

Published

on

A Certified True Copy (CTC) of the Supreme Court judgment on the political crisis in Rivers State has shed light on why the apex court restored the Hon Martin Amaewhule-led leadership of the State House of Assembly.

The apex court in a 62- page judgement obtained on Thursday by our correspondent made it clear that there was no iota or shred of evidence to support the claim of defection made against the 27 members of the House of Assembly from the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) to the All Progressives Congress (APC).

To worsen the situation, the Supreme Court in the judgement signed by Justice Emmanuel Agim said that the Rivers state governor, Siminalayi Fubara who raised the allegations of defection against the 27 lawmakers on his own volition withdrew the allegations at the Federal High Court in Abuja.

By not supporting the defection claim against the Amaewhule-led leadership, the apex court held that in the eyes of the law, no defection has taken place and consequently the status quo in the House of Assembly must remain.

Justice Agim, who endorsed the judgement copy specifically held that there cannot be any House of Assembly unless as prescribed by the 1999 Constitution, adding that the Constitution did not envisage or support the position of governor Fubara to recognize only four members as the authentic House of Assembly.

Consequently, the apex court held that it is an aberration for Governor Fubara to make any request, nominations and presentations to the Rivers State House of Assembly unless the one led by Hon Martin Amaewhule and believed to be loyal to former governor Nyesom Wike faction.

“What is clear from the above concurrent findings is that the 8” respondent (Fubara) started the prevention of the sittings of the Rivers State House of Assembly constituted by the number of members as prescribed by Section 96 of the 1999 Constitution long before the issue of the remaining 27 members defecting to another political party arose.

“The said activities of the 8” respondent (Fubara) were adjudged by the concurrent holdings of the Court of Appeal in its Judgment in Appeal No. CA/ABJ/CV/133/2024 as illegal and unconstitutional long before the allegation of defection started.

“Against the background of these concurrent findings and holdings In the Court of Appeal Judgment in Appeal No.CA/AB)/CV/133/2024, i is reasonable to conclude that the cross appellant’s reliance on Sections 102 and 109 of the Constitution and the doctrine of necessity is to continue his brazen subversion of the Rivers State House of Assembly, The 1999 Constitution and legitimate government in Rivers State.

“Having by his own admission engaged in a series of illegal activities just to prevent the other 27 members of the Rivers State House of Assembly from participating in the proceedings of the House to carry out their legitimate legislative duties which they were elected to do, his resort to Sections 102 and 109 of the 1999 Constitution and the doctrine of necessity on the basis of his allegation that they have defected is a red herring to perpetuate his subversion of the Rivers State House of Assembly, the 1999 Constitution and democratic government in Rivers State.

“The 8th respondent (Fubara) had collapsed the Rivers State House of Assembly. Therefore no question about any member having lost his seat in that House due to defection can validly arise. There must be a House of Assembly for any constitutional processes therein to take place.

“The daim that the 27 members are no longer members of the House on the basis of an alleged defection is a continuation of his determination to prevent them from participating in the proceedings of the House. It Is an engagement in chicanery.

“Sections 102 and 109 of the Constitution cannot be invoked in aid of this unconstitutional enterprise. Section 102. of the Constitution that provides that “A House of Assembly may act notwithstanding any vacancy in its membership and the presence of any person not entitled to be present at or to participate in the proceedings of the House shall not invalidate such proceedings”, cannot be relied on to validate the proceedings of a House of Assembly in the absence of over 90% of the members or to justify a vacancy created by the illegal exclusion of a member of the House or to justify the contrived illegal exclusion of 27 members and officials from the House and illegal shutting down of the House by destroying the legislative building and House of Assembly complex and blocking access to the place by legislators and officials of the House.

“A government cannot be said to exist without one of the three arms that make up the Government of a State under the 1999 Constitution. In this case, the Executive arm of the Government has chosen to collapse the Legislature to enable him govern without the Legislature as a despot. As it is there is no government in Rivers State.

“The doctrine of necessity cannot be invoked to justify the continued existence of a deliberately contrived illegal or unconstitutional status quo. It cannot be invoked to justify and protect the illegal actions of the 8” respondent and his despotic rule of Rivers State without a House of Assembly.

“It applies to genuine situations that were not contemplated in the provisions of the Constitution or any law, which situations require the taking of some legitimate extra constitutional or extra legal actions to protect public interest.

“The 8″respondent’s fear of impeachment by the House Assembly is no justification for his attacks on the House of Assembly, the Constitution, the Government of Rivers State and rule of law.

“Political disagreements cannot justify these attacks and contempt for the rule of law by the Governor of a State or any person. What the 8” respondent has done is to destroy the government because of his fear of being impeached.

“In the light of the foregoing, I hold that Cross-appeal No SC/CV/1175A/2024 lacks merit and is hereby dismissed.

“The part of the judgment of the Court of Appeal affirming the judgment of the Federal High Court in Suit No. FHC/AB)/CS/984/2024 is hereby affirmed. The said judgment of the Federal High Court in Suit No.. FHC/AB)/CS/984/2024 is hereby restored.

“For avoidance of doubt it is hereby ordered that the Central Bank of Nigeria and the Accountant General of the Federation should forthwith stop releasing and paying to the Government of Rivers State, its organs, departments and Officials any money belonging to Rivers State until an Appropriation Law is made by Rivers State House of Assembly constituted as prescribed y the !999 Constitution.

“The Rt Honorable Martin Chike Amaewhule and the other 26 members should forthwith resume unhindered sitting as Speaker and members respectively of the Rivers State House of Assembly.

“The Rivers State House of Assembly Should resume sitting with all elected members forthwith.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

US insists Nigeria must remain Country of Particular Concern

Published

on

The United States government has insisted that Nigeria should retain its Country of Particular Concern, CPC, designation, saying the country has not done enough to protect Christians from attacks.

Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs, Frank Garcia, made this statement on Thursday during a congressional hearing on violence in Nigeria.

Garcia was responding to questions from US Congressman Riley Moore, who asked about the government’s efforts to dismantle militia strongholds and kidnapping camps in the Middle Belt, particularly in Benue and Plateau states.

Moore also raised concerns over the exclusion of the states from the forest guard initiative and delays in deploying 1,000 approved guards to Plateau.

“Before you answer that, we cannot take this CPC designation off of this country. They have not done enough,” Moore said.

Garcia acknowledged the lack of progress, but said Nigeria was taking steps to address the concerns, although they had yet to produce results.

He said the country’s security capacity was still being developed and that deployments were not happening fast enough.

“Unfortunately, the violence has not stopped,” Garcia added, citing continued attacks in Kaduna and Plateau states.

He said the US had provided police training and equipment, expanded intelligence sharing and worked with Nigerian financial institutions to disrupt terrorist financing.

Garcia added that Washington would continue diplomatic engagements and security cooperation to protect vulnerable communities and ensure accountability.

However, the Nigerian government has consistently rejected claims of a “Christian genocide” or targeted religious persecution, maintaining that insecurity affects Nigerians of all faiths.

Continue Reading

News

Cooking Gas price goes up to N1,800/kg

Published

on

Liquefied Petroleum Gas, commonly known as cooking gas, has risen significantly, forcing Nigerians to spend more to purchase the product.

The increase comes as depot owners and retailers raised their prices over the past two days.

StockGap increased its depot price by N25 to N1,440 per kilogram. Nigerian Independent Petroleum Company Limited, NIPCO, Mobil (now 11 Plc) and Ardova, on the other hand, sold the product at N1,400 and N1,390 per kilogram, respectively.

Similarly, LPG retail outlets, including Raniol, Juda Oil and Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited, NNPC, outlets in Abuja and its environs, now dispense cooking gas at between N1,550 and N1,600 per kilogram, up from N1,400 and N1,500.

Micro-LPG dealers sell the product for between N1,700 and N1,800 per kilogram, depending on the location in Abuja.

Earlier, NIPCO’s spokesperson, Taofeek Lawal, had exclusively told DAILY POST that LPG prices could increase further between November and January next year.

The latest price increase means that Nigerians who previously spent N17,500 to refill a 12.5kg cylinder at N1,400 per kilogram will now pay N20,000 at the new rate of N1,600 per kilogram, representing an additional N2,500.

Continue Reading

News

2027: Tinubu Must Withdraw ‘All Is Fair in Politics’ Remark, Embrace Peaceful Coexistence — ADC-PCC

Published

on

The African Democratic Congress Presidential Campaign Council (ADC-PCC) has called on President Bola Ahmed Tinubu to publicly retract his controversial “All Is Fair in Politics” remark, warning that such rhetoric fuels political division, emboldens thugs and poses a grave threat to the nation’s peace and stability.

The ADC-PCC also expressed concern over what it described as the President’s disturbing silence on the conduct of some APC governors and party chieftains who have openly made inflammatory statements and allegedly encouraged political violence.

In a statement signed by its Director of Media and Publicity, Kola Ologbondiyan, the ADC-PCC urged President Tinubu to rise above partisan interests and demonstrate the statesmanship expected of a national leader, citing former President Goodluck Jonathan’s unequivocal declaration that no presidential ambition was worth the blood of any Nigerian.

The Council described as shocking the President’s failure to condemn the growing wave of political violence, noting that, through his spokesman, Mr. Bayo Onanuga, the Presidency had instead chosen to caution opposition parties while shielding those allegedly responsible for violence within the ruling APC.

“President Tinubu cannot claim to desire peace when his own words provide cover for violence.

“‘All Is Fair in Politics’ is not the language of a Head of State. It is the language of political desperation and an open licence for thuggery, ballot snatching, intimidation and bloodshed.

“From Edo to Cross River, Gombe to Lagos, and Kebbi to Kaduna, Nigerians have witnessed attacks on opposition gatherings, destruction of campaign materials and the brutalisation of innocent supporters, allegedly by APC-sponsored thugs.

“Yet, Mr. President has not considered it necessary to call his governors and party members to order.

“Instead, the Presidency has resorted to diversionary tactics, blaming victims and preaching restraint to the opposition while members of the ruling party are accused of unleashing violence across the country,” the statement said.

The ADC-PCC challenged President Tinubu to explain why his condemnation of political violence appears directed at the opposition rather than members of his own party.

It asked: “Why has Mr. President refused to condemn APC governors who openly threaten opposition supporters? Why has he remained silent over public incitement by officials of his party? Why is his anger always directed at the opposition and never at those within his own political fold?”

The Council maintained that the ADC remains committed to peaceful, issue-based political engagement, insisting that its campaign is focused on addressing the country’s pressing challenges, including hunger, insecurity, unemployment, corruption and what it described as the failures of the Tinubu administration.

It accused the APC of resorting to violence because it had little to offer Nigerians in terms of credible solutions to the country’s problems.

Consequently, the ADC-PCC demanded that President Tinubu immediately and publicly withdraw his “All Is Fair in Politics” remark, condemn and call to order APC governors and party officials accused of inciting violence, and direct security agencies to protect all Nigerians impartially rather than allow them to become instruments of intimidation and oppression against opposition parties.

” Nigeria belongs to all of us. No political ambition is worth the blood of any Nigerian.
“If former President Goodluck Jonathan could make that profound declaration in 2015, President Tinubu has no excuse not to say so and demonstrate the sincerity of his commitment to peace in 2026.

“The ADC will not be intimidated. We will continue to campaign peacefully, and in 2027, Nigerians will have the opportunity to vote for competence, integrity and a new beginning,” the statement added.

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2023 Thebigeye